Public debt is generally presented as an instrument of collective solidarity, enabling the State to finance its expenditure, support economic activity and preserve its social model. But what happens when this instrument, which is supposed to contribute to the redistribution of wealth, ends up having the opposite effect? This is the paradox that Jean-Marc Daniel addresses in this book with its deliberately provocative title.
The author first invites us to go beyond the usual perceptions of public debt. This is neither intrinsically virtuous nor necessarily reprehensible. It can be used to finance useful investments, to cushion economic crises or to spread the cost of certain expenditures over time. But it becomes problematic when its continuous accumulation gradually transforms a financing instrument into a redistribution mechanism for the benefit of capital holders.
This is where the central thesis thesis of the book comes in, that of Robin Hood reversed, or Robin Hood While the famous character took from the rich to redistribute to the poor, the indebted state collects taxes from all taxpayers, including the least well-off, to remunerate the holders of government securities, generally from the wealthiest categories. The interest burden thus becomes a transfer of income whose redistributive consequences redistributive effects may run counter to the stated objectives of fiscal policy.
Jean-Marc Daniel also places the focus of his analysis and reasoning not only on the debt but also on its source: the budget deficit. He introduces the concept, which is dear to him, of the cyclical dynamics of the economy, which covers various mechanisms creating periods of expansion and recession. He distinguishes between the “good deficit”, the cyclical one, a kind of overdraft that allows one to get through times of crisis, and the one that should be eliminated, the structural deficit, the gap between the amount collected in taxes and the amount of public spending.
True to his approach as a historian of economic thought and to Turgot, whom he does not forget to mention, the author draws on experiences of restoring public finances to argue for the need to restore sustainable budgetary discipline. It is not a question of condemn all recourse to borrowing, but to recall that debt cannot cannot be a permanent substitute for political decisions, budgetary trade-offs decisions and structural reforms.
The value of this essay lies in this reversal of perspective. It reminds us that the economic and social consequences of debt social consequences of debt are not measured solely by its amount or by the level of interest rates, but also by the way in which it changes the distribution of income and the scope for public action.
At a time when France is struggling to to control its deficits, the book ultimately poses a fundamental question: can a state credibly claim to correct inequalities in the long term when the financing of its own expenditure contributes to creating new ones?